Luxury Unfiltered: The self-inflicted luxury crisis

October 23, 2024

Daniel Langer is the founder and CEO of consulting firm Équité

In the wake of disappointing Q3 financial results from major luxury players like LVMH, Kering, and Porsche, challenging times for luxury brands are evident.

In almost all cases, the financial reports are presented in the context of “challenging headwinds, particularly in China.” The key question, though, is what is the root cause?

When we investigate the details, it becomes clear that the luxury sector is grappling with a crisis of its own making, not just a market downturn.

Poor storytelling
For the last two years, I have published many articles warning that brands that don’t adapt to the rapidly changing expectations of luxury clients will not remain successful.

In fact, we are now seeing the biggest divide ever between successful brands growing at significant, often double-digit rates, while others decline, often also in double digits. The polarization between the best brands and the worst-performing ones is increasing.

When we work on luxury strategy projects, we always conduct brand and category audits where we go into an in-depth assessment not only of our clients but also of all major competitors. This assessment goes far beyond typical competitive analyses and includes meticulous reverse-engineering of brand stories and assessments of the perception of these stories by luxury clients.

Because of this, I have access to probably the most comprehensive brand analytics in the luxury industry across categories. With every brand audit, I can predict the future success of all key players within a category with high precision.

Typically, I find three issues that almost always put brands into a nosedive: The number one issue is poor brand storytelling.

I estimate that at least 90 percent of today’s luxury brands significantly underperform because their brand storytelling does not create any meaningful client-centric value. Brands that still define themselves through “quality, craftsmanship, and expertise” in today’s world will fail utterly.

Therefore, not surprisingly, most of my strategy projects center around retooling brand storytelling to make it client-centric. It is the number one root cause for underperformance.

Second, most brands are what I call “luxury in ambition only.” They are well-packaged versions of the ordinary.

But luxury, as I have published over many years, is essentially “extreme value creation.” Hence, there is no room for anything but the extraordinary in all aspects.

Now I invite you to reflect: when was the last time a brand gave you a truly extraordinary experience that was consistently mind-blowing? Therefore, once we update brand stories, we immediately work with clients on overhauling their client experience strategy so that the brand story becomes tangible in extraordinary ways.

Third, and related to it, within organizations, luxury training on identifying the emotional key of clients, on emotional clienteling and on gaining confidence to inspire the world’s most discerning luxury customers is critical.

Strategic failure
I am just returning from such a training that I led in India for the client-facing team of a leading global luxury brand. Making people understand the psychology of luxury clients is critical for success.

Extreme value creation at all touchpoints only happens when organizations take excellence in every client-centric aspect seriously. But in reality, I still observe too much lip service in organizations – great ambitions and wonderful goals – but because real issues are not solved, most brands don’t generate enough desirability and leave millions of revenue and profit opportunities on the table.

This is fatal in a reality where practically all luxury brands increased prices in an unprecedented way without increasing their client-centric value proposition. Many did it because they thought they could and because everyone else did it.

Consumers are increasingly questioning the justification for these inflated prices as many brands have failed to elevate their offerings or experiences accordingly. It does not take a genius to understand that this puts many brands into a mismatch between perceived value delivered and prices asked for.

Since the value of any luxury brand fundamentally lies in storytelling, any deficits haunt brands even more severely.

Another dramatically neglected root cause for the crisis many brands face stems from their inability to engage effectively with affluent Gen Z consumers. This generation is not satisfied with random high-priced goods that carry a fancy logo. They demand meaningful stories, emotional inspiration and experiences that align with their values.

Brands that continue to rely on outdated narratives and fail to innovate are simply irrelevant in their eyes. Moreover, engaging Gen Z requires a fundamental shift in how to approach innovation and communication. This demographic expects seamless integration of digital experiences with physical products.

Compounding these challenges is the shift in Chinese consumer behavior towards a growing preference for local brands and purchases made outside China, signaling a need for brands to rethink their strategies. Chinese clients still crave luxury. They are just smart enough to understand when brands provide them value and when they don’t.

Lean in
As outlined earlier, the heart of the issue lies in the lack of emotional brand storytelling and inspiration. The essence of luxury is not in selling products; it is about taking humans on an emotional journey that transforms their experience, mesmerizes them and creates lasting positive memories.

Yet many brands persist with generic stories that fail to differentiate them in an increasingly crowded market, a phenomenon I often call the “sea of sameness.” To navigate this self-inflicted crisis, luxury brands must urgently transform their approach by investing in developing inspiring client-centric brand storytelling that connects deeply with consumer insights and emotional drivers – values and aspirations alike.

Engaging Gen Z requires innovation and an understanding of their high expectations for authenticity and cultural relevance. When I discuss this with boards of companies and luxury leadership teams, I still too often see misunderstandings about what brand storytelling truly is. It’s not an advertising campaign or a PR stunt.

It’s providing internally and externally clarity on the fundamental emotional brand promise; it’s about defining “what are we really selling.”

Now is the time to act decisively to inspire and engage your audience or risk fading into irrelevance. The call for transformation is urgent as many luxury brands stand at a crossroads where complacency is no longer an option.

They find themselves here because they don’t generate enough inspiration or desirability at all touchpoints; transformative change is needed now more than ever before. Invest heavily into crafting compelling narratives around your unique offerings while ensuring every interaction leaves customers feeling truly “wowed.”

Are you delivering upon promises made within your marketing efforts? Or merely aspiring towards something greater without actually achieving those lofty goals? Be honest. For if not addressed soon enough others will inevitably seize upon opportunities left unclaimed.

Luxury Unfiltered is a weekly column by Daniel Langer. He is the CEO of Équité, a global luxury strategy and brand activation firm. He is recognized as a global top-five luxury key opinion leader. He serves as an executive professor of luxury strategy and pricing at Pepperdine University in Malibu and as a professor of luxury at New York University, New York. Mr. Langer has authored best-selling books on luxury management in English and Chinese, and is a respected global keynote speaker.

Mr. Langer conducts masterclass management training on various luxury topics around the world. As a luxury expert featured on Bloomberg TV, Financial Times, The New York Times, Forbes, The Economist and others, Mr. Langer holds an MBA and a Ph.D. in luxury management, and has received education from Harvard Business School. Follow him on LinkedIn and Instagram.

Share your thoughts. Click here

Luxury Unfiltered: The self-inflicted luxury crisis

Follow @LuxuryDaily for the latest in luxury news

Ginori 1735, St. Regis Hotels partner to scale branded cafe concept

Mytheresa releases quarterly results, reaches record high AOV

Erewhon to pilot pop-up juice bar in Las Vegas during F1 weekend

Audemars Piguet unveils collaboration with artist Kaws

‘Copy Nothing’ campaign defines next era at Jaguar

Luxury Unfiltered: Hermès and Patek Philippe prove trust is the true luxury

Jaeger-LeCoultre brings ‘Reverso Stories’ to New York

Dolce & Gabbana, Skims release limited-edition collection

Pomellato reveals exclusive residency at Bergdorf Goodman